i actually think Caleb will be the one to die!
i have nothing to back it up but the whole Ravenswood talk with Hanna and the ouija board moving to “Goodbye” while they’re talking is enough for me.
i believe the, Melissa hit/killed Bethany, theory is too obvious.
so i was re-watching, A Is For Answers, and as Alison and Byron are done talking the focus goes to a set of shovels up against some wood planks.
like i said the Melissa theory is too obvious, for me at least.
i believe Bethany was also wearing a yellow top that night, Byron returned to the backyard - grabbed a shovel walked a few steps then saw Melissa talking to someone in a yellow top, Bethany. From behind he hit Bethany thinking it was Alison and she fell to the ground.
at this point i believe Melissa was so shocked that she just pushed Bethany’s body into the hole and began shoveling the dirt.
i honestly believe Byron had something to do with Bethany’s murder.
i’m not one to write a theory i just love reading them.. feed back would be appreciated and welcomed!! tell me if you agree or if you think i’m just stupid and should stick to reading theories and watching episodes quietly! x